Home Improvement, Issue III: Real Life Intrudes
This is what happens when you lose internet access -- stale rage. But I guess stale rage is better than none at all.
+++++++++++++++++++++
Sept. 4, 2005
It’s easy to lose perspective, especially in our contingent cube and computer-based world where so many of us are disconnected from the phenomena that makes up the real world. That is, of course, until the real world barges its way into the bubble you’ve created for yourself. To paraphrase Leon Trotsky, “you may not be interested in the hurricane, but the hurricane is interested in you.”
The whole world has seen the devastation wrought by Hurricane Katrina in the Gulf Coast. Its power and the destruction it caused amazes. The internet/news media/blogosphere is full of accounts of what happened there which are far superior to anything I could convey. But what has happened here in Washington, DC over the past week has astounded me more than a Category Five hurricane – and that is something I can say something about.
The measure of a person is taken when the chips are down. The men who drafted the Constitution are rightfully praised because they created a document that protects our essential rights even when the urge to revoke them is greatest – soldiers being quartered in people’s homes doesn’t happen during peacetime, it happens in war, and the Constitutioneers knew that kind of coercion should be outlawed even when some saw the need for it (hear me, Mr. Ashcroft?).
By contrast, I’ve never seen such a staggering failure of character and leadership as I have from the top members of our government as I have in the last week. While New Orleans – the country’s second largest port and way station for billions of dollars worth of oil, gas, farm products and other commodities, not to mention home to almost a million Americans – flooded, the President, Secretary of Homeland Security Chertoff, and FEMA Director Brown did…what, exactly? The President, while suspending the Clean Air Act so refineries could run at full steam so the rest of American could get cheap gas, talked about relief like it was a years-long project instead of an ongoing crisis. Chertoff and Brown offered laundry lists of tents and pounds of ice instead of taking control or offering any creative solution – “hey, let’s parallel park an aircraft carrier to block off the lake” or “we need the Army to ‘invade’ the city to preserve law and order.” I've seen better problem solving in an After School Special.
Meanwhile, we have been subjected to stories alternating from the best we’ve seen in human nature – men and women pushed to the brink in efforts to help total strangers – to phantasmagorical accounts of a Hobbesian war of all-against-all.
The little things get to me the most. I raged at the TV after seeing Chertoff and Brown in neatly pressed suits – a haggard and rumpled Brown would have at least seemed to be doing something. The story of how a rescue crew from Vancouver, BC was able to make it to St. Bernard parish before the National Guard or FEMA brought me as close to crying in public as I’ve been since I was ten.
Crisis management is a bit of an oxymoron. No matter how much we train and plan crises, by their very nature, catch us by surprise. This is why people’s mettle is tested in crises – they either step up or they don’t, and you really get to see where their priorities fall. Would Director Brown picking up a shovel or wading into the lower Ninth Ward to deliver water and food to exhausted disaster workers have made the difference? Only a little, but it would have at least illustrated that he realized how desperate the situation had become. Instead, we got boneheaded comments on how he hadn’t realized that there were over 15,000 refugees stranded at the New Orleans Convention Center until CNN asked him to comment on it.
I believe in government, and I believe that the people who serve in our government can make a difference. But government doesn’t always have the answers. When it doesn’t, the least I expect from our leaders – as I do from everyone – is to do the right thing. Caught without a plan? Pick up a shovel. Is the National Guard stuck in Iraq? Then commandeer every traffic helicopter in the region and throw them into the rescue effort. But do something. Doing nothing in negligent and cowardly. If your response is “I can’t” then you certainly don’t deserve to be heading up a family or a small business, much less the government of the United States of America.
In the weeks to come we’ll likely hear countless stories of individual heroism – of people doing the right thing. We’ve seen some of that already. Governor Rick Perry of Texas, a conservative Republican with whom I agree on almost nothing, did the right thing by accepting refugees and guaranteeing a spot for every Louisiana child in his states’ public schools. Shep Smith of FOX News did the right thing by abandoning any pretense of journalistic detachment to communicate the utter desperation he was witnessing. Anderson Cooper of CNN laid the wood to Sen. Mary Landrieu on the air when she offered empty platitudes of thanks to her Senate colleagues while, according to Cooper, rats were feasting on corpses of bodies left to rot in the streets (how is it that the news media was able to get into the city so easily while the Pentagon acted like it was airlifting the National Guard to Pluto?).
Some of you reading this probably don’t like what I have just said. Maybe you think I’m being political and that is not the time for ad hominem attacks. If you think accountability and character are inherently political ideas, feel free. What would be terribly political, in my mind, is fake comity or a too-well crafted appeal for “unity” or “cooperation” in the hopes of offending no one while fellow Americans – our people – are dying.
Today I’ll do what I can. I’ll gather clothes for New Orleanians headed to the DC Armory. My wife, a native New Orleanian, is working at a phone bank.
What will you do?


